datasheets.com EBN.com EDN.com EETimes.com Embedded.com
PlanetAnalog.com
TechOnline.com

Events ▼

EE Live!

DesignCon

ESC Brazil

ESC
India

ARM TechCon

Designers of Things

UBM
Tech

UBM Tech ▼

datasheets.comEBN.comEDN.comEETimes.comEmbedded.comPlanetAnalog.comTechOnline.com

EDN

About
Us· Subscribe to Newsletters

DESIGN CENTERS

Latest

Analog

Automotive

Components|Pkging

Consumer

Designcon

DIY

IC Design

LEDs

Medical

PCB

Power
Management

Sensors

Systems
Design

Test|Measurement

Wireless|Networking

Loading...

TOOLS & LEARNING

Latest

Design
Tools

Products

Teardowns

Fundamentals Courses

Webinars

Tech Papers

Courses

EDN
TV

Mouser New Products

Loading...

COMMUNITY

Latest

Blogs

Design
Ideas

Events

Loading...

CONNECT WITH EDN

ON TWITTER
ON FACEBOOK
ON LINKEDIN

EDN VAULT

Latest

Collections

Issue
Archives

Loading...

Search

DESIGN CENTERS

Analog

Automotive

Components|Pkging

Consumer

DIY

IC
Design

LEDs

Medical

PCB

Power
Management

Sensors

Systems
Design

Test|Measurement

Wireless|Networking

TOOLS &
LEARNING

Design Tools

Products

Teardowns

Fundamentals
Courses

Webinars

Tech
Papers

Courses

Mouser
New Products

COMMUNITY

Blogs

Design Ideas

Events

EDN
VAULT

Collections

Issue
Archives

Home>
Analog Design Center >
How To Article

Analog: back to the future, part one

Steve
Taranovich -June 05, 2012

Tweet

Save Follow

Save
to My Library
Follow
Comments
Follow
Author

PRINT
PDF
EMAIL

Click here to download a PDF

Examining history provides an eye-opening education into our predecessors’
successes and failures and may provide lessons on what to avoid and what to
emulate in our lives. This fact holds true not only in daily life but also in
analog-IC and analog-circuit design. Innovative developers and developments were
the foundations that led to 21st-century analog products that we now use in
design. This article delves into early precision-op-amp development from
National Semiconductor, Texas Instruments, and Linear Technology. Future
installments will focus on Burr-Brown, Analog Devices, Microchip, and Maxim and
on pioneers in analog technology.

At A
Glance

- National Semiconductor designers provide a snapshot of
the challenges of IC design from 30 to 40 years ago and how those
experiences brought about today’s ICs.

- Designers developed
so-called kludge boxes to verify the performance of designs and sometimes
later used them in production-test equipment.

- Designers used
simulation tools for validation, but they had to first perform manual
calculations, and breadboarding was standard practice until the
mid-1980s.

- Bob Dobkin, Linear Technology’s co-founder, vice
president of engineering, and chief technology officer, spent his early
design days at National Semiconductor, where his creativity was evident in
moving early op amps beyond the 1-MHz-bandwidth barrier.

Genesis of the op-amp IC

By experiencing
and learning from their growing pains along the course of IC development, a few
designers stand out. Several of these designers were originally with National
Semiconductor but are now part of Texas Instruments, and they are guiding
chip-design engineers along a new path of success for the next level of ICs that
circuit designers so desperately need in today’s demanding market. According to
Dennis Monticelli, TI fellow, the story of computers is also the story of IC
development; you can’t separate them. His co-worker, Chief Technology Officer
Erroll Dietz, remembers the early days of analog ICs as the “Wild West of
electronics.” Using design rules that they made up as they went along, these
designers worked from transistor-kit parts, used copper-clad breadboards with
sockets as design tools, and employed discrete resistors and capacitors
(Figure 1).

“Kit parts were transistors manufactured in the linear
IC-fab lines bonded up in metal can packages,” says Mike Maida, a distinguished
member of the technical staff at TI. “Design rules [used] spacing to adhere to
in IC layouts—for example, base to isolation, emitter inside base, [and the
like]. Designers sometimes figured out their own [design rules] for special
situations, such as reduced voltages, although the fab engineers had to sign off
on them. We had little mylar ‘rulers’ to measure spacings on the IC composite
drawings.”

The designers performed simulations using Level 2 Spice, which
used an enhanced Grove equation, the most common MOS equation in all simulators.
HKJ Ihantola and JL Moll in 1964 developed the equation (Reference 1). A
discontinuity in transconductance at the time made life difficult for designers.
Designs operating at frequencies higher than a few megahertz were difficult to
breadboard, for example. “Simulation is a late-’70s thing,” says Maida. “No one
simulated linear ICs [then].”

“There was a large discontinuity in the Level 2 MOS model for the region between
strong inversion and weak inversion,” says Don Archer, also a distinguished
member of the technical staff at TI. “When operating in the quasi-subthreshold
region, model discontinuity was a major problem for convergence, and, when we
started, there was no modeling group. We measured kit parts and came up with our
own model parameters.”

The designers also lacked the ability to capture
schematics; they had to manually type the netlist, including emitter, base, and
collector values, and manually generate a schematic to check the accuracy of
those values. They then added the simulation-node numbers to the hand-drawn
schematic. The lines in the netlist might read, for example, Q1 8 7 4 0 NPN1,
which would mean that Q1 is device type NPN1, with a collector node
of eight, a base node of seven, an emitter node of four, and a substrate node of
zero. They had to type a similar line for every transistor, resistor, and
capacitor.

“To look at waveforms, we had to use plot and print [commands]
to specify nodes to be printed or plotted,” says Farhood Moraveji, technical
director at TI. “For more complex circuits with hierarchy, we had to use [a
subcircuit command]. Back-end tools didn’t exist or were primitive. DRCs
[design-rule checks] and LVS [layout-versus-schematic] checks were not
automatic, and peers used to perform independent, manual LVS checks to verify
that the circuit and the layout matched.”

Layout tools included a “beer
check,” during which the designers placed circuit plots onto a light table.
“You would invite your peers to the beer check for your IC layout,” says Archer.
“You would buy them a beer for every mistake they found. We later got a more
staid design manager, who insisted we call them layout checks instead of beer
checks.”

Tweet

Save Follow

Save
to My Library
Follow
Comments
Follow
Author

PRINT
PDF
EMAIL

Next: Kludge
boxes

<
Previous

Page 1 of 3
Next >

Loading comments...

Write a Comment

To comment please Log In

Most
Popular

Most
Commented

System
level design and integration challenges with multiple ADCs on single chip

Understanding
the basics of setup and hold time

Product
How-to: Digital isolators offer easy-to-use isolated USB option

Managing
noise in the signal chain, Part 2: Noise and distortion in data converters

War
of currents: Tesla vs Edison

Simple
reverse-polarity-protection circuit has no voltage drop

Control
an LM317T with a PWM signal

Start
with the right op amp when driving SAR ADCs

Helping
board designers work with high-performance timing

Design
calculations for robust I2C communications

Op-Amp
Current Sources: The Howland Current Pump

Single-IC-based
electronic circuit replaces mechanical switch

Adding
Hysteresis to comparators

Techniques
minimize switching-device failures in inductive circuits

RELATED CONTENT

Nokia
Siemens Networks joins the Multicore Association

NI
Acquires Chip Software

An
improved chopper-stabilized op amp - part 1

EDN
Hot 100 products

TI
quiets the noise with innovative 1-A power converter

FEATURED RESOURCES

Subscribe to RSS:
or

Analog

Automotive

Comms|Networking

Components|Pkging

Consumer

DIY

IC
Design

LEDs

Medical

PCB

Power
Management

Sensors

Systems
Design

Test &
Measurement

Blogs

Design Ideas

Products

Tools

DESIGN CENTERS

MORE EDN

Analog

Automotive

Components
& Packaging

Consumer

DIY

IC
Design

LEDs

Medical

PCB

Power
Management

Sensors

Systems Design

Test &
Measurement

Wireless/Networking

Blogs

Design Ideas

Tech
Papers

Courses

Webinars

EDN TV

Events

About Us

SUBSCRIBE TODAY!
SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTERS
TODAY!  DON'T MISS ANOTHER ISSUE OF EDN IN YOUR INBOX!

GLOBAL NETWORK

EE Times Asia

EE Times
China

EE Times
Europe

EE Times
India

EE Times Japan

EE Times Korea

EE Times
Taiwan

EDN Asia

EDN China

EDN Japan

TechOnline
India

ESC
Brazil

ESC
India

FEATURED UBM TECH SITES:

EE Times

|

EBN
|

EDN
|

DataSheets.com

|

Embedded

|

TechOnline

|

Planet
Analog

OUR MARKETS:

Business
Technology
|

Electronics
|

Game
& App Development

Working With Us:

Advertising Contacts
|

Event
Calendar
|

Tech Marketing Solutions
|

Corporate Site
|

Contact Us / Feedback

Terms
of Service
|

Privacy
Statement
|

Copyright
© 2014 UBM Tech, All rights reserved